General Interest

why the south was right in the civil war

Everyone knows what the American Civil War was all about, right? Second, they were traitors and rebels which is unacceptable considering all the violence and destruction their war caused. There is no reason to believe that the South was right in their position. Yes, slavery was an evil that needed to be abolished but, according to the constitution, that was a decision to be made at a state level. Since the North won the war, the federal government has grown in power and now believes it has full authority over state governments. This is why our founding fathers led a revolution against the British, And I would remind JMan that realistically they were "rebels" guilty of treason against the king. I respect the Confederates for their determination and great fighting skills, but I do not believe their cause was Just. BatmanoftheJLA. I only need to put this because I need an other 13 words, 1: Just because someone stops you from doing something, That does not mean that you just go on your own, Especially when they are in charge of you. Most of the fighting during the American Civil War took place on Southern soil. If he can march right through the heart of … It was the Confederacy that paid its black soldiers equal wages, Not the northern army. Here are ten basic facts you need to know about America's defining struggle. In this lesson, we'll look at the notion of states' rights and their role in the United States Civil War, as well as some examples of how states' rights were invoked regarding the question of slavery. Seidule clearly and comprehensively explains why the Civil War was, in fact, motivated by the South's desire to preserve slavery. Nevertheless, the war remains one of the most misunderstood events in American history. That is still 15% too much of people treating those of African decent poorly by whippings, poor living conditions, or selling off family members to other Southern whites. The civil war, however, was not fought on the issue of slavery. The Civil War was a series of battles between the North and the South over issues such as slavery and states' rights. Here are ten basic facts you need to know about America's defining struggle. Did the South secede because of slavery? It was fought because the Southern States had left the Union. This war is often described as "the bloodiest war," and many soldiers fought in the Civil War. Since civil war broke out in South Sudan in December 2013, over 50,000 people have been killed—possibly as many as 383,000, according to a recent estimate—and nearly … The Confederate States were fighting for their right to govern in a manner which would allow the state to survive economically. 2:when is slavery ever right in the entire universe. But tigether thr North &South form a mightier much more stable country, A country that has become one of the major, If not sole, World superpowers. Each region relied on one another for resources, and when it’s all just one country it is a lot easier to trade around. There were numerous reason behind why each side's soldiers fought for one side or the other. Since the north had more people they thought that they should have more people in the senate. There is no reason to believe that the South was right in their position. So what was it all about? The war was due to withdrawing of them from the Union. It is almost impossible to imagine the Civil War erupting without the passions aroused among Northern abolitionists and those in the South who saw slave-holding as central to their way of life. This all comes from the basic understanding of a fundamental principle stated by Thomas Jefferson in the Declaration of Independence, Originally taken from the philosopher John Lock. One main problem was that the states did not have enough power, and the fed was too powerful. The Civil War was about just one states' right: the right to own slaves. The Civil War was absolutely about slavery. Next, another reason that was believed to have caused the Civil War was that the south feared that the north would have the majority of the senate. Most importantly the War for Southern Independence expressed the inviolable right of the people to be self-governing. The south disagreed with … The reasons for the war and its outcome remain hotly debated. The agrarian system has worked very well for the South and made it very wealthy. Saying the Confederate States of America fought the entire war for slavery is as ludicrous as it is naively biased. That was the "states rights" they were fighting for. Nevertheless, the war remains one of the most misunderstood events in American history. The Civil War and its aftermath of hyper-federalism masked why the Deep South began secession after Lincoln's election in 1860. The South’s opposition to states’ rights is not surprising. I believe I have no lawful right to do so, and I have no inclination to do so." Slavery undermines the rights and freedoms due to all humans. Like a massive earthquake, the Civil War and the destruction of slavery permanently altered the landscape of Southern life, exposing and widening fault lines that had lain barely visible just beneath the surface. The main objective was to save the union. Not only that but not a single slave was freed during the war unless they fought in the armies. American Civil War, four-year war (1861–65) fought between the United States and 11 Southern states that seceded to form the Confederate States of America. American Civil War, four-year war (1861–65) fought between the United States and 11 Southern states that seceded to form the Confederate States of America. Unfortunately it was labour intensive and the northern traders were happy to import and sell slaves to the Southern cotton growers. Do you believe the South was in the wrong in the Civil War? They did not like being in a country that was, they felt, dominated by the North. The Confederacy was, Simply put, Too weak to stand by itself on the world stage with a small population, Weak industrial/infastructural base, And over reliance on an agricultural society it could not hope to compete with the powers of Europe at that time. In waging war, the South faced problems of politics and government that greatly complicated its problem of economic mobilization. It was in South Carolina that the Civil War began, when the Confederacy fired on Fort Sumter. Thats all I got. Slavery was permanently abolished in America and the United States was United once again. Cotton was a huge export earner for the US, North and south. If it is, Then it is not a true union at all. Students of all age groups know at least something about this war. If slavery was the main issue, than why didn't the North make slavery illegal and then go to war in order to support the law? The two sides involved in the American Civil War were the Union, which represented the North, and the Confederacy, which represented the South. It arose out of disputes over slavery and states’ rights. The state’s casus belli was neither vague nor hard to comprehend : They wanted to preserve Slavery to maintain their way of life as well as their economy, However, As history has proved time and again, A country cannot succeed off of slavery, So it would have been abolished anyways. The north trampled all over the south, by taxing their goods, restricting their congressional powers, and forcing the northern way of life on the south. The Civil War erupted from a variety of long-standing tensions and disagreements about American life and politics. The Civil War (1861–1865) was the bloodiest war in American history. General Lee expected Slavery to end on its own. In 1863 Lincoln abolished slavery in the South. The nation was shattered into North and South by blue and gray. Had very little to do with slavery and everything to do with money and power. As the North chose to abolish slavery without constitutional authority, they embraced the belief that that the end justifies the means, a philosophy that we find later in history with the advent of communism. Many of the monuments’ defenders have claimed that the Civil War was not about slavery but instead about states’ rights. Like Reply. States' Rights is seen as one of the major causes of The Civil War. The Civil War ended in December 1865, and the slaves were free. The South definitely won the Civil War. The Civil War profoundly shaped the United States as we know it today. The South started the actual war and then the North chose to fight back. Certainly not the constitution. While this may be a worthy aim, It is critical to understand that, As Andrew Jackson said, " the Union cannot be preserved through force. " The North was a greatly industrialized zone at the time, while the South was exceedingly agricultural. The war was basically about state's rights. The South’s inner civil war reflected how wartime events and Confederate policies eventually reacted upon the region’s distinctive social and political structure. The North's focus was not to end slavery but to preserve the union. Many Americans kept on discussing about the beginning of the Civil war. The South seceded before the new Republican government of Abraham Lincoln took any action to restrict slavery in the south or any other institutions of Southern states. Several Ron Paul supporters have asked that the video be taken down, from the pro-Confederate channel, Patriot Review but Patriot Review believes that the video could help Paul win South Carolina. The real issue was the South was an oligarchy of big land owners that ruled unfairly. Historians looked more closely at slavery, and saw a rapidly expanding, even thriving, system. The Civil War is a well-known war taught in every school. The American Civil War started on April 12, 1861 from open fire on Fort Sumter, and took place all across America. Their well-researched arguments demonstrate the South's many legitimate complaints during the antebellum period, including unfair taxation and unequal constitutional rights. The South had prospered in the 1850s, like the North, and when a financial panic had struck in 1857 the South, unlike the North, had largely escaped its effects. Next both sides would have kept or got ride of slavery to end the war. The Consent of the Governed. McClellan, in command of Federal forces in southern Ohio, advanced on his own initiative in the early summer of 1861 into western Virginia with about 20,000 men. The … During the Civil War, the North and South had several different views on the way of life. What gave Lincoln the right to actively STOP the rebellion. It arose out of disputes over slavery and states’ rights. Beginning as a battle of army versus army, the war became a conflict of society against society. There were many causes of the Civil war, but it is the results that are important. Fact #1: The Civil War was fought between the Northern and the Southern states from 1861-1865. During the civil war in the United States, southern states fought to maintain the right to keep slaves, while the north and the President fought to release them to freedom. When antislavery candidate Abraham Lincoln was elected president (1860), the Southern states seceded. Thank you. I also believe that the South, given time, would have ended slavery on it's own if they had won the war, but one state at a time as the constitution directs. The South has a Constitutional Right to leave the United States of America (States Rights, Secession). So goes the inevitable response when one brings up the Civil War within earshot of a Confederate apologist. After all, they were the same states that decided to accept the constitution and the authority of the federal government. Ron Paul is a neo-Confederate, and proud member of the Ludwig Von Mises Institute, which has been labeled as a neo-Confederate organization. Protectionist tariffs was another item the Confederate Constitution banned, Something the northern states desperately wanted because of the industrial advantage over the agricultural South. The Civil War profoundly shaped the United States as we know it today. The north did not fight to free slaves they fought for total control of the government. In part, this was the result of the war strategies of both sides. The North and its troops originally fought because they felt the South had no legal right to secede from the Union and was close to treason. Unfortunately, that success was achieved through the exploitation of millions of slaves, many of whom were brought to the United States against their will and then abused, tortured and killed in the name of building the South. Until the Civil War, Southern presidents and lawmakers had dominated the federal government. The two sides involved in the American Civil War were the Union, ... which represented the South. Abraham Lincoln commonly made racist remarks about blacks and actually said that he was really concerned that the Union be preserved. Abraham Lincoln started the war by sending soldiers in to another country (Fort Sumter) because he wanted to preserve the Union. First and foremost, Allowing a constitutional way of getting rid of something that was, Economically speaking, Impossible at the time while ensuring the sovereign responsibilities of states. It was the Confederate Constitution that banned the over sea slave trade, Not the U. S. Constitution. It was not because Lincoln had … To some extent yes but not nearly as much as people would have me believe. What caused the Civil War? 1 The War for States' Rights: Secession Crisis ; 2 National Constitution Center: Ron Paul: Secession is right, Civil War maybe not ; 3 John's History Vortex: The Legality of Secession in the United States ; 4 The Washington Post: Five myths about why the South seceded ; 5 The Post and Courier: History shows secession was about slavery Paul would also claim that he wouldn’t have voted for it at the time, putting him on the side of the racists in both the fight against slavery and the fight against Jim Crow segregation, the two defining struggles of Black people in America. Ron Paul has made no secret the fact that he thought that the South was right in the Civil War. It has become an accepted historical fact that the South could not have won the American Civil War. Secession was based on the idea of state rights (or "states rights," a variant that came into use after the Civil War). Report Post. Ron Paul has made no secret the fact that he thought that the South was right in the Civil War. The North’s advantages in finance, population, railroads, manufacturing, technology, and naval assets, among others, are often cited as prohibitively decisive. Make no mistake, slavery was behind everything that led to the American Civil War. Reasons for Civil War. Why was the Civil War Fought? What if the South won the Civil War? Ron Paul was also was the only member of congress to vote against honoring the Civil Rights Act Of 1964 on its 40th anniversary in 2004. north, the Union wins the civil war, seemingly beating the much weaker south quickly and easily, to the clueless onlooker, but the war was very hard fought through deadly battles and bloodshed, with both sides coming close to beating each other out, at one point or another. On the contrary, It was Ulysses S. Grant who owned slaves during the war, Not Lee. Despite being Michigan-born—and living, at various times, in the East and Midwest—I grew up hearing this claim. The South was fed up with the Union because of the corruptness that was sinking into the federal government. Did the North care about abolishing slavery? But it is erroneous to say that the death and mayhem of the "Civil War" (or revolution of 1863 as I prefer to call it) was all for the preservation of the institution of slavery. Do I think Northern 'Bullying' tactics such as tariffs and taxes was wrong? Forcing people to do what you want, Whipping them when they don't, Barely having enough to survive, It's just pure wrong doing that sort of actuions. People believe that the war happened keeping in view of the rights of the Southern nationals. The North and the South went to war for very different reasons. Each and every state has a constitutional right to succeed from the union. In any case, the rational for saying that states rights was the cause of the Civil War was wrong. All Rights Reserved. The education system in the South had virtually disappeared, along with the old plantation system. Thank you for hearing me out and may God bless you all. Songs About Living While Black In The U.S.A. After succession they fired on fort Sumter with no attempts to negotiate first. If Lee was right, historians need not look south of the Mason-Dixon line to explain the war’s outcome: the answer is simply the old story of the biggest battalions winning. The American Civil War (1861-1865) was one of the bitterest civil wars in the world. In this kind of war, the ability to mobilize economic resources, the effectiveness of political leadership, and a society’s willingness to keep up the fight despite setbacks, are as crucial to the outcome as success or failure on the battlefields. Southern cotton production in 1870 was half what it was in 1860. The South in reality was trying to assert it’s own authority over the North with the Fugitive Slave acts or the ruling of the Dread Scott decision. The discrimination system was really about social class more than skin color. 20 Tweets Dragging Roseanne Barr To A White Privilege Hell, Top 10 Most Politically Significant Bob Marley Songs, Nina Simone To Billie Holiday: 10 Civil Rights Protest Songs. The primary cause of the war was the status of slavery in the nation and its newly acquired territories. Wikimedia Commons A statue of Confederate General Robert E. Lee is removed from its perch in New Orleans on May 19, 2017. The Union definitely had a significant advantage with a higher population, more industry, and a more massive army. The following are nine of the many arguments that have been put forward for why the Confederacy lost. The south's main purpose was to keep their slaves. Few of their leaders even believed they were right. In their best-selling book, The South Was Right!, the Kennedy brothers dispel many commonly held beliefs about the Civil War. There were two sides; North and South. When Lincoln, who opposed slavery, was elected president, this caused conflict with the South, who viewed slavery as a way of life. The South was fighting for a number of things. In many areas, cropland was ruined, livestock lost, railroads destroyed, and billions of dollars in slave-related investments wiped out. Until the Civil War, Southern presidents and lawmakers had dominated the federal government. During the civil war in the United States, southern states fought to maintain the right to keep slaves, while the north and the President fought to release them to freedom. They were victims of discrimination by the upper class whites too. ... Before the war, South Carolina did more than any other Southern state to advance the notion that a state had the right to nullify federal laws, and even to secede from the United States. First off, they supported Slavery which is in itself morally wrong. In the years after the civil war, white southerners followed Lee’s cue, telling an emotionally powerful story of a heroic and noble struggle against overwhelming odds. The south seceded from the Union and fought the Civil War, not to uphold states’ rights, but to defend slavery. Their well-researched arguments demonstrate the South's many legitimate complaints during the antebellum period, including unfair taxation and unequal constitutional rights. Paul also fails to bring up the fact that it was the South that started the war by attacking the North in 1861. Ron Paul Was Implicated In Failed White Supremacist Island Invasion, Top 10 Racist Ron Paul Friends, Supporters. Why did the South Lose the Civil War? Therefore they have the same right to break the political bonds which tied them to the union. The Civil War in the United States began in 1861, after decades of simmering tensions between northern and southern states over slavery, states’ rights and westward expansion. What has not been discussed in this too much was the British aristocracy’s (and rumoured royal) hidden support for the CSA and desire to go to their aid. This was something I, myself, was also surprised to learn in my American Civil War History class when I … We, Too, Sing America! Slavery was legal in the North well into the conflict. Does it really matter that less than 15% of the Southern whites owned slaves.? The ensuing Civil War (1861–65) wrought immense destruction on much of the South, which emerged the loser in the conflict. To win the war, the South had only to survive. 1. Civil War to Civil Rights - Summary Report Civil War to Civil Rights Commemoration - Summary Report One hundred-fifty years ago, competing visions for the country and conflicting definitions of freedom led to a war that threatened the very existence of the United States. 150 Years After Fort Sumter: Why We're Still Fighting the Civil War North and South shared the burden of slavery, and after the war, they shared in forgetting about it. The South could not have existed for long without the economic and manufacturing might of the North. The problem is that he stopped the rebellion by force-not negotiation. Slavery undermines the rights and freedoms due to all humans. A second reason why the American Civil War was necessary was because our country needed both the South and North regions to survive. But two years later, violent conflict broke out after political disagreement between President Salva Kiir and former Vice President Riek Machar and the fighting continues to this day. It’s a pervasive myth, even outside the Old Confederate South. Civil War broke out in 1861 on the issue of secession. By the civil-rights era, historical interpretations of the war were shifting. If they do take it down,  Charles Johnson at Little Green Footballs has downloaded a copy of the video. This exalted the powers of the individual states as opposed to those of the Federal government. They are nothing if not predictable. Recent Developments. Not only did they oppress African-Americans, but also, lower class whites. Would it be better to say that we could fight a war if 50% or 75% of Southern whites owned slaves? And certainly the North's main objective was not to abolish slavery, though it was an objective. I'm not here to address an argument over whether the South could have won the War. The right of property in slaves was recognized by giving to free persons distinct political rights, by giving them the right to represent, and burthening them with direct taxes for three-fifths of their slaves; by authorizing the importation of slaves for twenty years; and by stipulating for the rendition of … Jefferson Davis himself actually wrote in letter to his wife that slave property in the South would "eventually be lost. " The victorious North rewrote history to justify its invasion of the South, which was legally and culturally a separate, independent country… Yes, I do, The federal government had no buiseness screwing with the economy of states whom they did not know enough about to pass judgment on. The very issue that created the Confederacy helped to destroy it. This war lasted from 1861-1865 and divided the nation into the “north” and the “south”. what if the south won the civil war alternate history The war did not start because of slavery, it was a war for states rights. When antislavery candidate Abraham Lincoln was elected president (1860), the Southern states seceded. American Civil War - American Civil War - The land war: The first military operations took place in northwestern Virginia, where nonslaveholding pro-Union Virginians sought to secede from the Confederacy. Most importantly the War for Southern Independence expressed the inviolable right of the people to be self-governing. The basic reason why the South wanted to win in the American Civil War was so that they could govern themselves. Then after they took office they managed to pass Jim Crow laws and Black Codes. Here he is giving a speech in front of a giant Confederate Flag about why he believes the North was wrong in the Civil War and why the South was right. Civil War wasn't to end slavery Purposes: The South fought to defend slavery. the south wanted more individual state rights,some wanted slavery,and some wanted to secede.But slavery wasn't the main reason for the civil war He's trying to demonstrate that the South has no power that can prevent the North from prevailing in this war. The South was desperate for British intervention. In many ways, the North and South were fighting for the same thing in the Civil War: their right to maintain a way of life that worked for them. Not surprisingly, in the south there were high levels of discontent, which came to a head in 1955-1972 with the First Sudanese Civil War, then again in the Second Sudanese Civil War … For nearly a century, the people and politicians of the Northern and Southern states had been clashing over the issues that finally led to war: economic interests, cultural values, the power of the federal government to control the states, and, most importantly, slavery in American society. The abolition of slavery itself was never a direct Union war aim until 1863 when Lincoln issued the Emancipation Proclamation , declaring freedom for over three million slaves in the South. And while it’s true that the North did not go to war to free the slaves — they fought to preserve the union — the South went to war to preserve one states’ right: the right to own slaves. The South Was Right!, the Kennedy brothers dispel many commonly held beliefs about the Civil War. The confederates could never have been considered the good guys in the civil war.They supported slavery which many would consider one of the worse sins ever and they wanted to split the union up which could also be considered a pretty bad sin considering it was important to Lincoln that the union stay together. Fact #1: The Civil War was fought between the Northern and the Southern states from 1861-1865. The effects stem way past wanting slaves just cause the have no rights and they wanted to own. On the other hand, for the North to win, the Union had to be restored. The disaffected regions would embrace the Republican party after the Civil War; some remained strongholds well into the twentieth century. … By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. The Civil War was in reality the War for Southern Independence - freedom from rigid economic controls by northern industrialists who influenced government - NOT an issue of slavery. 2 The confederacy was GOOD!! As Confederate Vice President Alexander Stephens put it, … There were numerous reason behind why each side's soldiers fought for one side or the other. They viewed the North as Tyrannical, Imposing taxation and unfair legislation that hurt the South financially. North was mainly industrial and the south agricultural and the north wanted to out law slavery which would be detrimental to the souths agriculture. The South was Right. The South’s inner civil war not only helped weaken the Confederate war effort but bequeathed to Reconstruction explosive political issues, unresolved questions, and broad opportunities for change. In the video he claims that the North should have paid to buy slaves from southern slave owners to avoid the war, rather than the South renouncing slavery. The south was right and they should have won. South wanted to keep slavery, but North opposed slavery and thought it was not right. It generally rested on the theory of state sovereignty-- that in the United States the ultimate source of political authority lay in the separate states. The Civil War was in reality the War for Southern Independence - freedom from rigid economic controls by northern industrialists who influenced government - NOT an issue of slavery. First, the South couldn’t have won the civil war because state’s rights prevented unification of the South. An extensive amount of effort has gone into studying the American Civil War. Since civil war broke out in South Sudan in December 2013, over 50,000 people have been killed—possibly as many as 383,000, according to a … The North and its troops originally fought because they felt the South had no legal right to secede from the Union and was close to treason. In 2011, South Sudan gained independence from Sudan, marking an end to Africa's longest-running civil war. The Civil War had a huge effect on the United States of America, but especially on the former Confederacy in the South of the country. Even though the breaking point of the States' Rights argument was the issue of slavery, the states' rights issue has been debated since the beginning of America's Independence, as debated between Hamilton and Jefferson. T he South saw President Lincoln as a threat to their way of life and upon his election, South Carolina immediately seceded and many other states followed. They hoped to be treated as equal citizens who could vote, gain an education and live peacefully and equally with the whites. As Confederate monuments come down across the South, the Civil War has once again become a lightning rod throughout the United States. Do I think the war was about slavery? They caused the deaths of hundreds of thousands of young men. So the poor whites were getting the short end of the deal by supporting slavery or segregation laws. The South’s opposition to states’ rights is not surprising. People take the Civil War three ways ONE: Your with the South and your racistTWO:Your not with the South and you take racism the wrong way and you act racist like XXX THREE:Your with the North and you hate slavery. Many people still do not believe that Civil war occurred because of slavery. Copyright © 2020 Interactive One, LLC. Before the war, the South’s economy had been based almost strictly on agriculture, mainly cotton, tobacco, and sugar, and all these industries suffered, especially cotton.

William Ramsay Discovered, Installing Plywood Underlayment Over Subfloor, Travian Raiding Guide, Ryobi Ogs1822 One+ Plus Cordless 2-in-1 Grass Shear And Shrubber, Short Scale Electric Guitar Strings, John Frieda Violet Crush Purple Shampoo, Joomla Meaning In Urdu, Properties Of Eigenvalues Of Symmetric Matrix, Vegetarian Curry Cookbook, Big Data Variety, Penguin Cute Cartoon,